The self-organised cytoplasm
- Trevor Dale (Cardiff University, United Kingdom)
- Richard Sear (University of Surrey, United Kingdom)
- Ignacio Pagonabarraga (CECAM EPFL, Switzerland)
- Andrew Flaus (National University of Ireland, Ireland)
The cytoplasm and nucleoplasm of cells has a highly dynamic mesoscale structure. We define the mesoscale as being from of order a hundred nanometres to the size of the cell, which is typically of order 10 micrometres for eukaryote cells. Recent work has shown that we have been dramatically underestimating the extent of this mesoscale self-organisation, and its role in key processes of the cell function. This unique workshop will bring together the interdisciplinary group of scientists needed to advance this field.
Two specific mechanisms for dynamically creating self-organised structure on these lengthscales will be considered. The first is the action of molecular motors moving along cytoskeletal elements. This includes both direct transport by the motors, and the flow they induce. The second is the formation of phase-separated liquid-like droplets in the cytoplasm. These droplets are generally in dynamic equilibrium with the rest of the cytoplasm and form self-organised non-membrane bound compartments in the cytoplasm or nucleus. They are from around 100 nanometres to several micrometres across.
There are numerous examples of motor-driven functional dynamics inside cells, and on mesocale lengthscales. For example, the transport of mRNA by motors, and the role of motors in cell division. Droplet-like structures also occur in many cell systems. Examples are P granules, the puncta of cell-signalling proteins such as Dishevelled, and droplets of the anti-viral protein TRIM5alpha that appear to bind to HIV capsids. The two mechanisms of motor transport and droplets can operate in tandem, for example, droplets can be transported by motors. This structure and dynamics is clearly functional, disrupting it is known to impair function, but in many cases it is not fully understood why this structure is required. In other words we do not understand why the biological function requires this structure, as opposed to the function being performed by freely diffusing proteins in a uniform cytoplasm.
It is now widely appreciated that cells are complex systems, that require a systems biology approach to understand. But systems biology approaches often assume free diffusion in a uniform cytoplasm. The cytoplasm is self-organised, and much more complex than this. So this common assumption in systems biology is clearly incorrect here, and the workshop will explore what models and computational approaches will be needed to produce reliable models of these complex multiscale systems. It will bring together those who study these structures together with systems biologists and computational physicists.
We aim to bring together, for the first time, a unique combination of scientists with the diverse range of skills required to advance our understanding of these phenomena. This involves bridging a number of discipline boundaries. One boundary is between physical and biological scientists, but there are others. For example, that between systems biologists and those studying soft matter physics behaviour such as motors and phase separation. Speakers include physicists who study both motors and phase separation, together with cell biologists studying these processes in cells.
We will also invite systems biologists, who can consider the functional role of these processes in the context of cell processes such as cell signalling. Speakers will include computational modellers, and both cell biology and physical science experimentalists. They will also include some doing in vitro experiments, others working in vivo in animal cells, and scientists working in bacteria. This is a unique combination that will only be brought together by this workshop.
Both motor-driven transport and phase separation are known to be essential components in key cell processes, which in turn are involved in diseases including cancer and HIV. For example, droplets of signalling proteins function in the Wnt cell-signalling pathway, and mutations in proteins of this Wnt pathway are common in both bowel and breast cancer. Therefore, moving our understanding forward here has the potential to advance our understanding of these major diseases. These diseases are major challenges to society in the 21st century.
We break our outline of the state of the art into 4 sections: 1) Functional liquid droplets in cells, 2) Self-organised transport, forces and flow in cells, 3) Protein solution phase behaviour in vitro and in silico, and 4) Statistical physics and fluid mechanics of active matter.
In each area we will try and set out the state of the art, and indicate how we think this can be advanced by the collaborations we propose to encourage in the workshop.
1) Functional liquid droplets in cells. The cytoplasm is very far from uniform and structureless. Liquid-droplet-like structures have been studied in many cells. Examples are P granules (Brangwynne, 2009), stress granules (Ruggieri, 2012), the puncta of cell-signalling proteins such as Dishevelled (Fiedler 2011; Sear, 2007), and droplets of the anti-viral protein TRIM5alpha that appear to bind to HIV capsids (Campbell, 2007). Motor transport and droplets can operate in tandem, for example, droplets can be transported by motors (Campbell, 2007; Brangwynne, 2009). These self-organised droplet-like structures are known to be functional (disrupting them can alter function). But how most of this self-organisation contributes to function is unknown. Modern experimental techniques can now provide quantitative information on key properties such as turnover rates, but simple models and computer simulations are lacking. Systems biology approaches are needed for many aspects of cell behaviour, but these use ODEs or in some cases multiple static compartments (Lloyd-Lewis, 2013). Here, improved modelling of the droplets would allow us to advance the state of the art in systems biology approaches to these systems. There are models and simulations on phase separation controlled by active processes dating back to the 1990s (Glotzer, 1995) but these have not been used to model data from cell biology experiments. There are also 'whole cell' models - models with an explicit spatially-resolved whole cell volume. They have been applied to study systems with protein clusters (DePristo, 2009). But so far these have only been applied to bacteria (DePristo, 2009), not to the much larger and more complex, and hence much more computationally demanding, eukaryote cells.
2) Self-organised transport, forces and flow in cells. Cells contain a dynamic cytoskeleton, with actively polymerising and depolymerising actin filaments and microtubules, each with molecular motors moving along them. These have been shown by cell biologists to be used by the cell to localise multiple entities in the cytoplasm, such as mRNA (Holt, 2009) and P granules (Brangwynne, 2009). This is typically by towing a cargo that is directly attached to the motor, but motors can also induce flows (Ganguly, 2012), which in turn affect transport and localisation (Trong, 2012). All these processes dramatically affect the rates at which protein molecules encounter each other in the cytoplasm. However, almost all modelling in systems biology assumes a well-mixed uniform cytoplasm in which molecules encounter each other at a rate that scales as the number of protein molecules divided by the total volume of the cytoplasm (Lloyd-Lewis, 2013). In many cases active processes associated with the cytoskeleton mean that this is not correct. A systems biology approach is essential to model many key aspects of cell behaviour such as proliferation and differentiation but the ODE models which are the state of the art here are clearly very crude approximations. More realistic models of the behaviour are required, and they need to be rooted in an understanding of the basic physics of the self-organised cytoplasm, to ensure that they are generalisable and robust.
3) Protein solution phase behaviour in vitro and in silico. Protein solutions often undergo liquid/liquid phase separation, forming liquid droplets. How this relates to protein interactions has been studied (Voets, 2012; Zhang, 2012). This experimental work on protein solutions has inspired theoretical and computer simulation work to calculate not only the phase behaviour of models of proteins, but also non-equilibrium phenomena such as gelation (Rovigatti, 2013; Dorsaz, 2011). This combination of computer simulation and experiment has resulted in a good basic understanding of the interactions of at least some simple proteins in solution, and how these interactions control behaviour such as the formation of droplets. This is now ready to be extended to the in vivo situation. But to do this, collaborations with cell biologists are required.
4) Statistical physics and fluid mechanics of active matter. This is a rapidly advancing field of physics. Our understanding of the fundamentals of the behaviour of these systems has matured greatly over the last 10 years; see the review of Marchetti et al. (2012). This has required the development of advanced mesoscopic simulation tools. The knowledge developed in past decades is now ready to be applied to a wider range of problems in cell biology. In particular we believe that it is now ready to contribute to improving the models of dynamic cell processes in systems biology models. For example, to replace simple second order reaction ODEs with more accurate expressions for reactions in the dynamic self-organised cytoplasm. Also, computer simulations have recently been applied to study the collective dynamics of transport on a crowded cytoskeleton (Neri, 2013), and interesting results such as the spontaneous formation of dynamic heterogeneties have been found. But these results have not yet been applied directly to biological problems such as mRNA transport and localisation in cells.
Brangwynne CP, Eckmann CR, Courson DS, Rybarska A, Hoege C, Gharakhani J, Jülicher F, Hyman AA, Germline P granules are liquid droplets that localize by controlled dissolution/condensation, Science 2009, 324, p1729.
Campbell EM, Dodding MP, Yap MW, Wu X, Gallois-Montbrun S, Malim MH, Stoye JP, Hope TJ, Trim5alpha cytoplasmic bodies are highly dynamic structures, Mol Biol Cell. 2007, 18, p2102.
DePristo MA, Chang L, Vale RD, Khan SM, Lipkow K, Introducing Simulated Cellular Architecture to the Quantitative Analysis of Fluorescent Microscopy, Prog. Biophys. Mol. Biol. 2009, 100 p25.
Dorsaz N, Thurston GM, Stradner A, Schurtenberger P, Foffi G, Phase separation in binary eye lens protein mixtures, Soft Matter 2011, 7, p1763.
Fiedler M, Mendoza-Topaz C, Rutherford TJ, Mieszczanek J, Bienz M, Dishevelled interacts with the DIX domain polymerization interface of Axin to interfere with its function in down-regulating β-catenin, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. 2011, 108 p1937.
Ganguly S, Williams LS, Palacios IM, Goldstein RE, Cytoplasmic Streaming in Drosophila Oocytes Varies with Kinesin Activity and Correlates With the Microtubule Cytoskeleton Architecture, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. 2012, 109, p15109.
Glotzer SC, Di Marzio EA, Muthukumar M, Reaction-controlled morphology of phase-separating mixtures, Phys. Rev. Lett. 1995, 74 p2034.
Holt, CE, Bullock SL, Subcellular mRNA localization in animal cells and why it matters, Science 2009, 326, p1212.
Lloyd-Lewis B, Fletcher AG, Dale TC, Byrne HM, Toward a quantitative understanding of the Wnt/beta-catenin pathway through simulation and experiment, WIREs Syst. Biol. Med. 2013, doi: 10.1002/wsbm.221.
Marchetti MC, Joanny JF, Ramaswamy S, Liverpool TB, Prost J, Rao M, Aditi Simha R, Soft Active Matter, 2012, arXiv:1207.2929.
Neri I, Kern, N. Parmeggiani A, Modeling Cytoskeletal Traffic: An Interplay between Passive Diffusion and Active Transpor, Phys. Rev. Lett. 2013, 110, 098102.
Rovigatti L, de las Heras D, Tavares JM, Telo da Gama MM, Sciortino F, Computing the phase diagram of binary mixtures: A patchy particle case study, J. Chem. Phys. 2013, 138, 164904.
Ruggieri A, et al., Dynamic oscillation of translation and stress granule formation mark the cellular response to virus infection, Cell Host Microbe 2012, 12, p71.
Sear RP, Dishevelled: a protein that functions in living cells by phase separating, Soft Matter 2007, 2, p680.
Trong PK, Guck J, Goldstein RE, Coupling of Active Motion and Advection Shapes Intracellular Cargo Transport, Phys. Rev. Lett. 2012, 109, 028104.
Voets IK, Trappe V, Schurtenberger P, Generic pathways to stability in concentrated protein mixtures, Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 2012, 14, p2929.
F. Zhang, R. Roth, M. Wolf, F. Roosen-Runge, M. W. A. Skoda, R. M. J. Jacobs, M. Stzucki, and F. Schreiber, Charge-Controlled Metastable Liquid-liquid phase separation in protein solutions as a Universal Pathway Towards Crystallization. Soft Matter 2012, 8, p1313.